Index Back Forth
Rome, sestertius, Maximinus Thrax, Fides Militum
5.5.2023
..da Ancient Roman Coins.
Id. please
Is this coin fake or original?
 fig. 1
Cliccare sulle immagini per ingrandire
Rome, 7.5.2023
Dear,
below are the significant elements concerning the figure coin:

Æ Sestertius1, mint of Rome, January 236 - March/April 2382, RIC IV/II 78 (pag. 146), rarity index "C".

Summary description (parts worn or otherwise illegible of the legend are indicated in red):
D. MAXIMINVS PIVS AVG GERM3. Maximinus, laureate, draped and cuirassed bust right.
R. FIDES MILITVM4. Fides standing l., holding signum in each hand. S C5, left and right in the field.

The search on the web for coins of the type of figure gave rise to the following results:

  1. https://www.vcoins.com/it/stores/ken_dorney/52/product/maximinus_i_235__238_ad_sestertius_fides/1042737/Default.aspx €204.28 Quotazione: 05/05/23 Maximinus I, 235 - 238 AD, Sestertius, Fides MAXIMINUS I, 235 - 238 AD AE Sestertius, Rome Mint, 30mm, 21.55g Obverse: MAXIMINVS PIVS AVG GERM, Laureate, draped and cuirassed bust of Maximinus right. Reverse: FIDES MILITVM S C, Fides standing left holding signum in each hand. RIC78 Struck on a large flan, lovely dark patina with excellent surfaces.
  2. https://www.cngcoins.com/Coin.aspx?CoinID=40797 Image 0 Sale: CNG 64, Lot: 1168. Estimate $400. Closing Date: Wednesday, 24 September 2003. Sold For $300. MAXIMINUS I. 235-238 AD. Æ Sestertius (24.51g). Struck 236-238 AD. Laureate, draped, and cuirassed bust right, seen from behind / Fides standing left, holding military standard in each hand. RIC IV 78; Cohen 13. Good VF, dark brown patina.($400)..
  3. https://www.cngcoins.com/Coin.aspx?CoinID=70594 Sale: CNG 70, Lot: 821. Estimate $150. Closing Date: Wednesday, 21 September 2005. Sold For $150. MAXIMINUS I. 235-238 AD. Æ Sestertius (27.47g, 12h). Struck 236-237 AD. Laureate, draped, and cuirassed bust right / Fides Militum standing facing, head left, holding standards. RIC IV 78; BMCRE 139; Cohen 13. VF, dark green and brown patina, light smoothing in fields, small die break on neck. ($150).
  4. https://www.vcoins.com/it/stores/ken_dorney/52/product/maximinus_i_235__238_ad_sestertius_with_fides/1559752/Default.aspx €113.49 Quotazione: 05/05/23 Maximinus I, 235 - 238 AD, Sestertius with Fides Maximinus I, 236 - 238 AD. AE Sestertius, Rome Mint, 30mm, 17.13g. Obverse: MAXIMINVS PIVS AVG GERM, Laureate, draped and cuirassed bust of Maximinus right. Reverse: FIDES MILITVM S C, Fides standing left holding standard in each hand. RIC 78.
  5. https://auctions.bertolamifinearts.com/it/lot/9495/maximinus-i-235-238-sestertius-28mm-/ LOTTO 822 - E-LIVE AUCTION 38 Maximinus I (235-238). Maximinus I (235-238). Æ Sestertius (28mm, 14.51g, 12h). Rome, 236-7. Laureate, draped and cuirassed bust r. R/ Fides standing l., holding signum in each hand. RIC IV 78; Banti 4. Green patina, Good Fine - near VF.
  6. https://www.ma-shops.com/sondermann/item.php?id=1803&lang=it Prezzo 190,00 EUR Maximinus I. Thrax Sestertius, struck AD 235-236 at Rome mint. Obv: MAXIMINVS PIVS AVG GERM, laureate, draped and cuirassed bust right. Rev: FIDES MILITVM / S - C (in fields), Fides standing left, holding standards. 24,68g, 33mm. RIC 78.
  7.  https://www.cngcoins.com/Coin.aspx?CoinID=352150 412, Lot: 636. Estimate $200. Sold for $300. Maximinus I. AD 235-238. Æ Sestertius (30mm, 21.44g, 12h). Rome mint. 3rd emission, late AD 236-237. Laureate, draped, and cuirassed bust right / Fides standing left, holding signum in each hand. RIC IV 78; BMCRE 139; Banti 4. Good VF, green and red-brown patina. From the Matthew Rich Collection. Ex CNG Inventory 438704 (December 2016).
  8. https://www.cngcoins.com/Coin.aspx?CoinID=330050 391, Lot: 494. Estimate $150. Sold for $130. Maximinus I. AD 235-238. Æ Sestertius (29mm, 20.88g, 12h). Rome mint. 3rd emission, late AD 236-237. Laureate, draped, and cuirassed bust right / Fides standing left, holding signum in each hand. RIC IV 78; BMCRE 139; Banti 4. VF, dark brown patina, light pitting on obverse.
  9. https://www.cngcoins.com/Coin.aspx?CoinID=330051 391, Lot: 495. Estimate $150. Sold for $150. Maximinus I. AD 235-238. Æ Sestertius (30mm, 22.63g, 1h). Rome mint. 3rd emission, late AD 236-237. Laureate, draped, and cuirassed bust right / Fides standing left, holding signum in each hand. RIC IV 78; BMCRE 139; Banti 4. VF, dark brown patina, some red on reverse.
  10. https://www.cngcoins.com/Coin.aspx?CoinID=326381 387, Lot: 492. Estimate $100. Sold for $80. Maximinus I. AD 235-238. Æ Sestertius (33mm, 21.72g, 12h). Rome mint. 3rd emission, late AD 236-237. Laureate, draped, and cuirassed bust right / Fides standing left, holding signum in each hand. RIC IV 78; BMCRE 140-1; Banti 4. Near VF, gray and brown patina, some deposits, flan crack, slight die shift on obverse. From the estate of Thomas Bentley Cederlind.
  11. https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces280329.html Issuer Roman Empire (Rome) Emperor Maximinus I Thrax (235-238) Years 236-238 Value As = 1⁄16 Denarius Currency Antoninianus, Reform of Caracalla (AD 215 – 301). Composition Bronze. Weight 10.1g. Diameter 25mm. Shape Round (irregular). Technique Hammered. Demonetized Yes. Number N# 280329. References RIC IV.2# 80, OCRE# ric.4.max_i.80.
Coming to conclusions, the physical characteristics of the coin are missing and a comparative examination with the authentic coins of the period is not possible. On a separate page I have compared the coin in question with ten authentic samples found on the web. The result of the comparison is that the coin is probably authentic, while its market value in the present conditions does not exceed, in my views, thirty euros.

Best regards.
Giulio De Florio

--------------------------------------------

Notes:
(1) In principle, since the physical characteristics are not known, the figure coin could be both a sestertius (Ric 78) and an as (Ric 80 - see link11). In practice, however, asses are not so frequent on the market, which is why it is much more likely that the sample under consideration is a sestertius rather than an as. I collect in the table below the physical characteristics of the sesterces of the type of figure taken from the links above:

References Weight(g) die axis(h) Diameter(mm)
Link1 21,55 - 30
Link2 24,51 - -
Link3 27,47 12 -
Link4 17,13 - 30
Link5 14,51 12 28
Link6 24,68 - 33
Link7 21,44 12 30
Link8 20,88 12 29
Link9 22,63 1 30
Link10 21,72 12 33
In the absence of the physical characteristics of the sample under examination, it will not be possible to carry out a comparative examination with the genuine coins of the period, nor to determine with certainty the type of nominal.
(2) I draw from the Ric the dating of the sample in question, January 236 - March, April 238,
(3) MAXIMINVS PIVS AVG GERM (MAXIMINVS PIVS AVGustus GERManicus). Maximinus, Emperor from 235 to 238 d. C., was a Thracian peasant family endowed with great height and physical prowess. He entered the ranks of the army at the time of Emperor Septimius Severus, where he had risen to become governor of Mesopotamia. In 235 he was on the Rhine frontier when a military revolt led to the murder of Severus Alexander and his mother Julia Mamaeas, encamped near Mainz (22 March 235 AD) and to the acclamation of Maximinus as the new emperor. He fought successfully against the Germans but in Rome he was opposed by the nobility and only reluctantly the Senate recognized him the title of Augustus. In late 235 or early 236, as a result of the successful campaigns against the Germans, Sarmatians and Dacians, he was awarded the titles of "Germanicus", "Sarmaticus", "Dacicus". In 238, first the rebellion of the Gordians against tax impositions in Africa, then that of the Senate that led to the rise of Pupienus and Balbinus, induced Maximinus to move against Rome. But, after an unsuccessful siege of the city of Aquileia, the soldiers mutinied, tired of the harsh discipline and the scarcity of food, and killed him together with his son Maximus Caesar.
(4) FIDES MILITVM. Fides was the Roman personification of trust, loyalty and oath. She was also venerated under the name Fides Publica Populi Romani (roughly “general trustworthiness of the Roman people”). According to tradition, Rome’s second king Numa Pompilius established annual festivals in honour of Fides, and instituted that the higher priests (the three flamines maiores) were brought to the temple in a covered vaulted chariot drawn by two horses. There they were to conduct Fides’ services with their heads covered and their right hands wrapped up to their fingers, thus showing absolute devotion to Fides and symbolising trust. There is historical evidence of the erection of a temple on the Capitol during the 1st Punic War. Its temple in Rome, consecrated in 254 BC by the consul Aulus Atilius Caiatinus, was located on the Capitol near the temple of Jupiter. Here the Roman Senate signed and kept treaties with other states, entrusting them to Fides’ protection. As a rule, a standing woman is depicted, usually with ears of corn and a basket of fruit or a cornucopia and bowl. She thus embodies the “Fides publica” – the promise of trust and loyalty between the emperor and the Roman people. In the later – and increasingly uncertain – imperial period, more and more issues of the “Fides militum” and the “Fides exercitus” were added, mostly with military attributes such as spear, sceptre, standard or aquila. These coins fervently invoke the loyalty of the legions and soldiers to their emperor. Since Maximinus Thrax was not very popular, he was particularly dependent on loyalty and fidelity as emperor. However, this did not help him - Maximinus was slain by his own troops in April 238 AD - more precisely: by soldiers of legio II Parthica.
(5) S C (Senatus Consulto, "by decree of the Senate") was the usual abbreviation affixed to the Roman bronze nominals (sesterces, dupondi and asses) to indicate the exclusive competence of the Roman Senate in decisions relating to the issues of those coins (the gold and silver coinage, which does not bear that acronym, fell instead within the direct competence of the emperor).
Index Back Forth